Part One: The Birthmark
The very first thing I actually noticed about the baby was her missing sock. The second thing was a familiar birthmark resting on her cheek. By the time I finally saw her mother’s name printed in the file, I already understood I wasn’t leaving that transitional care placement unchanged, not in any real sense.
I ran into Wesley at a diner off Route 14, for the first time in nearly nine years. He told me he’d personally been the twentieth family in a row to say no to a baby girl. “Twentieth,” he repeated. “They actually told us the exact number. Like knowing that was somehow supposed to make us feel better about it.”
I stared at him over my own coffee cup. “No to what, exactly?”
He turned his mug around twice on the table before finally answering. “She has Down syndrome. We got the call, we said yes at first, and then we actually read through her file, and we just… couldn’t go through with it.”
Wesley had always talked with his hands constantly, back when we were kids together. That particular morning, though, they stayed wrapped tight around his coffee mug the entire time.
I asked how long she’d already been waiting. “Fourteen months now. She’s currently in a transitional care placement over in Millhaven.”
He looked down at the table. “You’ve got real money. You’re entirely on your own these days. Maybe you could send something her way. Cover a few things for her.”
“I’ll think it over.”
Wesley nodded. For a while afterward, we talked about considerably easier things instead — people we’d both gone to school with, businesses that had shut down since we last spoke, how genuinely strange it felt that the old bowling alley had turned into a pharmacy.
Then I finally asked the one question I’d been carefully avoiding since coming back to town. “Do you ever hear from Willow anymore?”
Wesley stopped moving his mug entirely.
Willow had been my first genuine love. Not simply my first girlfriend. My actual first love. We started dating at seventeen and stayed together clear through most of college. I genuinely thought we’d end up married eventually. She thought so too, at least for a while.
Then life got complicated between us. I took a job up north. She stayed behind to care for her own mother instead. We tried the long-distance arrangement. We failed at it, eventually.
There was no real betrayal involved. No screaming breakup, either. Just two people slowly growing exhausted by distance, until every single phone call started feeling like some kind of obligation instead of a real connection.
The last time I actually spoke with Willow, nine years earlier, she told me plainly she couldn’t keep waiting around for a life that might genuinely never happen. I told her I understood. I honestly didn’t, not really, not back then.
Wesley rubbed his own jaw. “Nobody really sees her around anymore.”
“What exactly does that mean?”
He hesitated. “I heard she’d died.”
My stomach tightened hard. “What?“
“I don’t actually know for certain if it’s true.”
“Who told you that?”
“Somebody told somebody else. You know how this town works.”
“How long ago, roughly?”
“A year, maybe.”
I stared at him. Willow was thirty-seven years old. People like Willow genuinely weren’t supposed to become mere rumors passed around town.
I left that diner an hour later, but both stories followed me straight home. Willow, and the little girl waiting over in Millhaven. I barely slept a single hour that entire night.
Part Two: What the File Said
The next morning, I drove straight to Millhaven. I didn’t bother calling ahead first. That turned out to be my very first mistake.
The care center sat as a small building connected to a larger pediatric services campus nearby. A woman working the front desk explained plainly that I couldn’t simply walk in off the street. I couldn’t just meet a specific child purely because somebody had mentioned her over breakfast that morning. That was fair enough, honestly.
I gave her Wesley’s name. I explained exactly what he’d told me. She made several phone calls. Then she asked for my driver’s license and had me sit and wait.
Forty minutes later, a case aide named Faye came back out, carrying a little girl dressed in a yellow sleeper. “You’re Holden?”
“Yes.”
“This is Poppy.”
Poppy had exactly one sock on. Her dark hair stuck up slightly on one side. She stared at me steadily with wide brown eyes.
Faye asked, “Would you like to hold her for a moment?”
I genuinely wasn’t sure why I said yes. Maybe because I’d already driven thirty minutes to get there. Maybe because I already felt foolish enough, simply standing there.
Faye handed her over carefully. Poppy felt warm, and considerably heavier than I’d actually expected. For about five full seconds, she simply studied my face intently. Then she grabbed the edge of my collar and held on tight.
Faye smiled. “She’s genuinely quite friendly.”
I laughed softly. “I can definitely see that.”
Poppy made a tiny sound somewhere between a hum and a contented sigh. Then she turned her whole face toward me directly.
That’s exactly when I saw it. A pale brown birthmark, sitting high on her left cheek. Small, almost perfectly oval in shape. My chest tightened instantly.
Willow had carried one in nearly the exact same spot. When we were nineteen, she used to complain about it constantly. I’d kiss that particular spot and tell her plainly it was my absolute favorite thing about her whole face.
Poppy reached for my chin right then. I very nearly dropped her entirely, from the sheer shock of that memory hitting me all at once.
“Are you okay?” Faye asked, concerned.
“Yeah.”
I genuinely wasn’t. I stood there considerably longer than I’d actually meant to. Then I finally asked, “Can I see her file?”
Faye hesitated. “I can show you the nonconfidential placement summary, if you’re seriously considering learning more about her. Some information stays protected.”
“That’s entirely fine with me.”
She brought me into a small office. Poppy stayed behind with another staff member. Faye set a folder down in front of me. “It’s mostly medical history and placement records.”
I opened it up. Date of birth. Weight at birth. Diagnosis confirmed shortly after delivery. Cardiac screening results. Early intervention notes. Developmental evaluations.
Then I turned to the second page. I read one particular line through twice. Mother: Willow.
I genuinely couldn’t breathe. “Can I use your phone for a moment?” I asked.
Faye looked confused. “My own phone’s out in the car.”
She slid the desk phone toward me instead. I dialed a number I hadn’t called in nine full years — Willow’s own number. I still knew it by heart. It rang and rang, and nobody ever answered. No voicemail picked up either, nothing at all. I hung up. Then I tried calling again. The exact same thing happened.
Faye watched me carefully the entire time. I looked back down at the file. “What actually happened to Poppy’s mother?”
Faye’s whole expression changed. “She died during childbirth.”
I stared at her, unable to speak. I don’t actually remember sitting down, but suddenly I found myself sitting anyway. For several long seconds, I heard absolutely nothing except the low hum of the air conditioning unit overhead.
Willow had been dead for fourteen months already. Willow carried the exact same birthmark as Poppy. That same Willow who’d been my own first love. Her daughter had been sitting barely twenty feet away from me this whole time. And I’d only found out because Wesley happened to mention some unwanted baby over breakfast that morning.
I covered my own face with both hands. Faye gave me a moment to collect myself.
Eventually, I asked, “What about actual family? Anyone at all?”
“Her maternal grandmother was formally contacted.”
See more on the next page
