The girls fell asleep in a heap on my king-size bed before nine, still in their dresses, Pip clutching a stuffed rabbit with one ear.
Maren and I sat at opposite ends of my long kitchen island, not touching, a pot of coffee going cold between us.
“You first,” she said.
So I told her my version.
Seven years ago, we’d been together two years. I was twenty-six, working in my family’s real estate office, miserable in a suit. She was twenty-four, waiting tables and taking night classes in graphic design. We met when she spilled an entire tray of iced tea on me at a charity luncheon and then laughed so hard she couldn’t apologize. I was going to propose that spring. I’d bought a ring.
Then, one Friday in March, I came home and she was gone.
Her closet was empty. Her phone was disconnected. My brother, Silas, was waiting in the living room with a grim face and an envelope.
“I’m sorry, Ev,” he’d said. “Mom offered her a hundred thousand dollars to walk away. Maren took it. She left this for you.”
Inside was a note in what looked like Maren’s handwriting. I’m sorry. I took the money. Please don’t look for me.
“I didn’t look,” I said now, staring into my coffee. “I believed it. My mother had been against us from the start. It made sense. I took the job in our London office three weeks later. I didn’t come back for two years.”
Maren had gone very pale.
“I never wrote any note,” she said. “And I never took any money.”
Then she told me her version.
Two weeks before that Friday, my mother had invited her to lunch. Just the two of them. At the country club. Over salmon, my mother had slid a check for a hundred thousand dollars across the tablecloth.
“Everett has a future,” she’d said. “You’re a lovely girl. But you’re not part of it.”
Maren had torn the check in half and left it on the table.
“I didn’t tell you,” she said. “I was so ashamed. I thought you’d be angry with her. I thought it would wreck your family. I thought I’d handle it.” She laughed bitterly. “And that same week, I found out I was pregnant. I was going to tell you that Friday. I had the ultrasound picture in my purse.”
My heart was hammering.
“Thursday night, your family had a dinner. You were stuck at the office, remember? Your mother insisted I come anyway. Halfway through dessert, she announced her diamond bracelet was missing. The one your grandfather gave her for their fortieth anniversary.”
I remembered the bracelet. A wide band of diamonds. My mother wore it to every party.
“Your brother offered to help look,” Maren said. “He went through the coat room. And he came back holding my purse.” Her voice broke. “The bracelet was inside it. Wrapped in a napkin. I’d never seen it in my life, Everett.”
The kitchen was dead silent.
“Your mother called the police right there at the table. They arrested me in front of everyone. Felony grand larceny. That bracelet was worth eighty thousand dollars.” She wrapped her arms around herself. “I couldn’t make bail. I was in county lockup for three months. Pregnant. With four babies, it turned out.”
I couldn’t speak.
“I wrote to you. Three times. To your office, because I didn’t know if you’d moved out of your apartment. I begged you to come. I told you about the babies.” Her eyes filled. “You never answered.”
“I never got them.”
“I know that now,” she said quietly. “But for seven years, I thought you’d read them and thrown them away.”
In the end, her public defender had gotten her a deal. She pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor so she could get out before the babies came. Time served, probation. She gave birth to four premature girls two months later in a county hospital.
And she’d spent the six years since then with a theft conviction on her record, getting turned down for every decent job, every apartment, every lease.
“Last week, my landlord found out about the conviction,” she said. “He gave us three days to leave.”
Before she did, she took something else out. A small, creased black-and-white photo, soft at the corners from years of handling.
An ultrasound. Four tiny shapes, curled like commas.
“I kept it in my bra in county,” she said. “So the guards wouldn’t take it. I used to look at it at night and talk to them. I told them their daddy was coming.” Her voice cracked. “After a while, I stopped telling them that.”
I held that photo in both hands and couldn’t say anything at all.
She reached into her worn bag and pulled out a folded, much-handled sheet of paper. A copy of the police report.
Complainant: Cordelia Thorne. Property recovered by: Silas Thorne, family member, from purse of suspect.
I looked at my brother’s name for a long time.
Then I heard the elevator chime in the hallway outside my apartment.
Footsteps. High heels. A sharp, fast knock on my door.
“Everett,” my mother’s voice called through it. “Open this door. Right now.”
CHAPTER 3: THE WARNING
See more on the next page
